MrBlueLight wrote:There is no such thing as a 10. A 10 is a a picture of a supermodel all made up, with the picture taken in perfect angle and photoshopped.
Contrary of what you said, there is usually a consensus on what is physically attractive. That is how some gets selected as models, TV shows, and beauty pageants and others can only dream about such things. I usually ask myself that is this girl cute enough to stand a chance to make it in popular media for her looks? If the answer is yes, then she's probably no lower than a 7. Out of the first batch, I would say the original second girl (the girl with maroon hair and bright lipstick) has the looks of local TV show actress if that is what she looks like in real life. In the second batch, the first girl looks like what a typical model looks like in the Philippines.
There is a general consensus and girls who get rated highly on rate me sites or get selected to be in beauty contests are generally at least average/above average to almost everyone whereas girls who are rated 1-3 on rate me sites are generally no better than average for almost anyone.
Some factors have to do with individual preferences whereas other traits are universally sought after. For example, Newlifeinthephilippines may prefer very short slim girls with darker skinned Malay faces and bigger boobs whereas Rock likes more refined lighter skinned faces and fuller figured tall girls with with big hips/butt and proportionally long legs and narrower shoulders. But, I suspect both Rock and Newlife and most others here at least appreciate youthful poreless skin, symmetrical faces with proportions which approximate Golden Ratio (championed by DaVinci in human aesthetics), waist-to-hip ratios around 0.7, proportionally long legs, good teeth, high noses, etc.
Many or even most of us have some unique tastes regarding features too. So perhaps the easiest way to attract a girl you also find attractive is to go for the one who falls lowest by more conventional standards. For a simple example, if big boobs are a big deal for you and make a girl much more attractive in your eyes, you could find one with a less attractive face to reduce the competition. To most she might be a 4 but to your eyes, her big boobs bump her up a couple notches to say a 6 since breasts do so much for you personally. So she will appreciate you and you will appreciate you - win/win.