Israel and Jordan

Discuss culture, living, traveling, relocating, dating or anything related to Africa or the Middle East.
Post Reply
fschmidt
Elite Upper Class Poster
Posts: 3470
Joined: May 18th, 2008, 1:16 am
Location: El Paso, TX
Contact:

Israel and Jordan

Post by fschmidt »

My family spent about 2 weeks in Israel and a few days in Jordan.

Jordan is a disaster, more dysfunctional than Mexico. Things don't work and people don't know what is going on. I didn't spend enough time there to understand why this is. I was in Egypt 17 years ago and it seemed similar, but I was with a tour which prevents one from really experiencing the place. Something went seriously wrong in the Islamic world which was once a great civilization. When I have time, I would like to research what went wrong. I would probably start with the writings of John Bagot Glubb whose book on Muhammad I read during this trip. In Amman, most areas were conservative with women covered. But in a modern mall for the upper class, one saw modern styles.

Israel is a small country that is very diverse. We visited Jerusalem, Tel Aviv, Haifa, and Tzefat. Tel Aviv and Haifa are modern cities with ugly modern concrete architecture. The people are modern, much like in Southern Europe. When I was in Tzefat 17 years ago, it was a small religious town that I liked. It has changed since then, and become famous for Jewish mysticism, resulting a in a big new-age presence there. Madonna visited for this. Tzefat has lost its soul. The only city I liked in Israel was Jerusalem which is very different from the rest of the country. It is the only place in the Western world where modern culture is a clear minority. It is dominated by religious Jews and by Muslims. In the tourist places, modern tourists are everywhere, but outside of tourist areas, there is a clear sense of neighborhood. Most neighborhoods are fairly homogeneous and the values of the people there determine the feeling there. The usual Western skank styles are not common.

In the religious areas of Israel, particularly in Jerusalem, there are many sex-segregated buses where men sit in front and women sit in the back. This is enforced by Orthodox Jews who, rightly, believe in segregating the sexes. My family rode on one of these buses and it was very pleasant. How is this enforced? Read how a stupid American woman was beaten for failing to comply.

One general Israeli characteristic is directness. This is the opposite of America, land of the fake smile. In Israel, things are real; people's faces, food, buildings, etc. This is something I really appreciate.

Visiting Israel makes clear how much Jews vary. In my opinion, Israeli Jews have more in common with Israeli Muslims than they do with American (non-orthodox) Jews. Yet Jews seem to cling to a tribal concept that unfortunately has become racist in my opinion. While it is possible to convert to Judaism, it isn't easy. In Israel, assimilation into Judaism is discouraged, yet American Jews, who have almost nothing in common with Israeli Jews, are invited. These American Jews who move to Israel tend to live apart from Israelis since they really don't fit, being basically Americans. American Jews in Israel stick out and I find them quite repulsive.

My wife is a Catholic Mexican, but after seeing Israel, she wants to move to Jerusalem and convert to Judaism. This shows the attraction of a functional co-alpha culture to women who value providers. We went to the organization in Jerusalem that handles immigration of American Jews. It was very awkward. The place was entirely staffed by American women, who my wife and I despise. These women feel superior to the rest of the world for being Jewish and for being American. With the usual fake smile barely plastered on her face, our interviewer asked us why we wanted to move to Israel. My wife said because she doesn't like America and she likes Jerusalem. I was asked about my Jewish background and answered that I am only ethnically Jewish and have no other association with Judaism. Because I pass the racial test, my family can easily move to Israel.


Below are my answers to Tyrannus's questions from the nice-guy forum:
Orthodox Israel is the ideal Patriarchy?
Yes, Orthodox Judaism is closest to ideal Patriarchy of any existing culture that I know of. Women dress conservatively and the culture is monogamous. The sexes are kept apart.
Aren't they surrounded by atheists and warmongers there???
I am an atheist, so I don't think atheism is the problem. The problem is modern liberal feminist culture. This is a minority in Jerusalem, unlike in most of the modern world. And warmongers, well many Orthodox are themselves warmongers. The Orthodox have a 4000 year old perspective, during which Israel repeatedly was conquered by different forces. They view modern times are a continuation of this, and they want to the Jews to be the conquerors this time. I don't have a problem with this. My problem with Judaism is that they don't welcome others to join. I understand now that Judaism isn't fundamentally a culture, religion, or ethnic group. Fundamentally, Judaism is a tribe. But this tribe should be more willing to accept new members who want to join.
In what way is MX anarchist? Isnt that the best path to freedom? Anarchy?
No, and this is my problem with MGTOW. Mexico is every man for himself. There is no cooperation, so nothing works and there is no security. In Orthodox Judaism, there is strong cooperation and enforced rules, like the separation of the sexes. This is real patriarchy.
People are unreliable? Maybe that's good so that feminism can not run deeply there.
Yes, compared to America, almost anything is good (socially). But my view is:

patriarchy > anarchy > feminism

I am not satisfied with anarchy. I want patriarchy. This is why MGTOW is not good enough for me.
What advantage is there to living in an all Jewish transplanted slice of America with warmongering tendencies? I dont see it.
Israel is very different from America, even comparing Orthodox Jewish neighborhoods in America with those in Israel. The Orthodox Jews in America follow the American practice of ignoring everyone outside of their circle. If I lived in an Orthodox Jewish neighborhood in America, I would be ignored. But the Israeli culture is the opposite where people deal with each other directly. In Israel, I would either be thrown out or be accepted, either of which I find preferable to being ignored.

Returning to the trip, at the end of it, my wife wanted to move immediately to Jerusalem. But I am busy with work, trying to start a business, so I want to wait. We agreed that we will buy a house in El Paso and once my current business starts making money, we will buy a second house in Jerusalem and we will divide our time between these places.
stravelcostia
Freshman Poster
Posts: 15
Joined: February 16th, 2011, 2:21 am

Post by stravelcostia »

hey u have shared a great post.......
i would like to visit the place.......
u have shared great reviews......

thanks for sharing......

thanks......
User avatar
MrPeabody
Experienced Poster
Posts: 1790
Joined: April 13th, 2008, 11:53 am

Post by MrPeabody »

From the perspective of the Western matrix, something went wrong with Islam. This presumably has something to do with Islam's lack of modernization - the standard by which the West measures progress. The facts - Islamic patriarchy-based countries are increasing in population. The Western countries (including Japan) are decreasing in population - they are dying. So Islam could equally say - "What went wrong with the West?" The tyrannies that rule the Islamic world are, in fact, not Islamic, and were regimes imposed by imperial powers after World War I. Nasser, Saddam, the Bath party, Turkey, were all Western-style socialists who murdered and suppressed true Islamic clergy. The Wahabis of Saudi Arabia were a fringe Islamic sect hated by most other Islamic sects, and were thus suggested by Lawrence of Arabia who knew that if they controlled the city of Mecca, Islam would never unite. Divide and conquer has been the predominate imperialist strategy of control. Islam is currently working through the noxious effects of colonialism and are about to do their own version of an invasion of the dying Western beast.
fschmidt
Elite Upper Class Poster
Posts: 3470
Joined: May 18th, 2008, 1:16 am
Location: El Paso, TX
Contact:

Post by fschmidt »

Just to follow up. After returning to El Paso, I visited to the local Orthodox Jewish rabbi. He said that since my wife isn't Jewish, my kids aren't Jewish either, and so he can't do anything for them. I was pretty repulsed by the close-mindedness and unwillingness to accept outsiders. Based on this, I have doubts that Jerusalem would work well as a place to live for anyone except for an all-Jewish family. So I am no longer considering Jerusalem as a place to live. I will just stay in El Paso.

I read more about Islam. I read A Short History of the Arab Peoples, and based on that, I think the advanced Islamic cultures were the result of the combination of old Islamic integrity with old Persian culture. Somehow the integrity of old Islam has been lost.

I also tried reading the Quran, which was painful. To me, the Quran reads as ranting. There is little coherence and no story telling like one finds in the Bible. The Quran doesn't seem like a good foundation for a sane culture.

Of course something has gone wrong in the West. But I don't think high reproductive rates are enough to consider Islam a success. After the Roman Empire collapsed, Europe's population declined dramatically because the lack of civilization meant far fewer people could be supported. The same will happen when the West collapses now. A successful culture not only has a high reproduction rate, but is coherent enough to survive in a failing world.
odbo
Veteran Poster
Posts: 2117
Joined: January 6th, 2011, 5:40 am

Post by odbo »

Jerusalem and Judaism are different things
Post Reply
  • Similar Topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post

Return to “Africa and the Middle East”