Don't be an angry Asian
Posted: September 16th, 2007, 2:29 am
I originally wrote these for another forum, edited for posting here.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Many Asian American men today are upset at the perceived social injustice they receive in America. One thorny topic is the portrayal of Asian American men in Hollywood, and the stereotype of nerds and martial artists. A recent example is Masi Oka, aka Hiro Nakamura on NBC series Heroes. He's short, nerdy, wears glasses, and ends up wielding a katana in the TV series. How stereotype do you want? To quote Pat Morita, Asian actors are at times so type-casted, you have to speak English with an accent to get the job.
The US has made good progress since segregation era of 1960s. Examples include the infamous Rodney King case, and more recently Wen Ho Lee case where US Judge James A. Parker personally apologized to Lee, for his treatment and the federal government's abuse of power. However, socio-economic discrimination still exist. In my city the residents are mostly middle-upper class whites and Asians. One rare black resident said in an interview that when he stepped outside to mow his lawn, his neighbors called the cops and told them that they saw someone who "didn't belong in the neighborhood". Think I live in the deep South? Nope, I live in a friggin coastal city in California!
Anyways, back to Asian males. Like it or not Asians are a minority in North America, where white American culture is dominate (and exported around the globe). But I'm going to step aside and take a different approach on this.
People in different geographic regions tend to have their own distinct physical appearances and attributes. Common examples include darker skin versus pale skin, taller height versus. shorter height, etc. Prior to the spread of rail transportation, most people lived and died in the same area where they were born. Contact with outsiders were fairly limited for most, and you generally hanged out with your own people.
But things changed from late 1800s to 20th century -- revolutions, WW1, WW2, rail, personal auto, urbanization, etc. all contributed to mass shifting/migration of people. Then suddenly people who previously didn't mix much, found themselves living together in the same city. People with different physical attributes, skin color, facial appearance, body height, etc. all living in close proximity to each other.
A common physical attribute that is considered desirable for men is body height. What happens if you mix a group of people with taller genes, with a group of people with shorter genes in the same location? The presence of many taller men changes the general population's expectations, which often results in height discrimination in social and economic areas. This form of discrimination is called Heightism. It's like a transition from shorter kids being picked up in school playgrounds, to shorter men being picked on when they're adults.
Some of you might argue that there has always been a number of taller vs. shorter people in any racial or ethnic group. Yes there's a bell curve for every group, but what I'm referring to is mixing a group with a a bell curve to the right with another group that has bell curve to the left.
The average height of American men is 5'9", but 90% of American CEO's are 6' or taller. 30% of American CEO's are 6'2"+, while only 3.9% of US population is 6'2". There are many studies on this subject that you can research on the web. One report concludes that statistically, taller men make +$800/year per inch of height vs. shorter men in the US. Also, if you ask many American women, they want to date 6' tall guys. I have one Vietnamese lady friend who would only date men who are 5'10" or taller. What percentage of Vietnamese men are 5'10"+? If she still lived in Vietnam she wouldn't have this kind of expectation, but being here in Los Angeles, and seeing more taller men, changed her expectations in what is acceptable for a BF or husband. She's 5'4" BTW.
In China, some people go through extreme measures to increase their height via surgery. Why do you think they have to do that? Northern Chinese are about 3"-4" taller than Southern Chinese. In old days people stayed in their villages, now they get up and move around to the cities. An influx of taller men from Northern China changed people's expectations. Even if the taller Northerners are a minority, employers want to hire taller men and women want to marry taller husbands.
What are the Chinese Navy's requirement for recruits?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/4762803.stm
"Good looking, tall (1.7m+), and polite."
So you see, while many Asians complain about being discriminated in the US because of physical attributes, the same level of discrimination exists back home too. We have laws against discrimination based on age, gender, race, but not physical appearance and body height. Why is that? A Vietnamese male friend of mine, who's 5'2", asked me that question once, but I had no answer for him (more on what happened to him in later post).
I picked height discrimination, because that's a fairly universal issue that most of you, regardless of race or background, can identify with. There are many other areas where men, or specifically Asian men might be discriminated against in a highly competitive environment. If you find yourself in such situation, you have the choice of either fighting harder (becoming more competitive), relocate to another environment that's more favorable to you, or "exit" the game and find happiness doing something else. Do not under any circumstance become an Angry Asian like Kenneth Eng:
http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f ... 7/HATE.TMP
http://wcbstv.com/local/local_story_222133357.html
If you want to relocate to another country, to an environment that'd be better for you, ask Ladislav and Winston for some advice. They have a lot more experience living abroad than me and can point you to the right direction.
But if you want to stay and fight it out, read on! For those from 1.5 gen, your parents worked hard to bring you to America so you can have a better life. So what if the dating scene is more competitive? Let's tie that rising sun hachimaki, chant fighto fighto and give it a shot!
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Many Asian American men today are upset at the perceived social injustice they receive in America. One thorny topic is the portrayal of Asian American men in Hollywood, and the stereotype of nerds and martial artists. A recent example is Masi Oka, aka Hiro Nakamura on NBC series Heroes. He's short, nerdy, wears glasses, and ends up wielding a katana in the TV series. How stereotype do you want? To quote Pat Morita, Asian actors are at times so type-casted, you have to speak English with an accent to get the job.
The US has made good progress since segregation era of 1960s. Examples include the infamous Rodney King case, and more recently Wen Ho Lee case where US Judge James A. Parker personally apologized to Lee, for his treatment and the federal government's abuse of power. However, socio-economic discrimination still exist. In my city the residents are mostly middle-upper class whites and Asians. One rare black resident said in an interview that when he stepped outside to mow his lawn, his neighbors called the cops and told them that they saw someone who "didn't belong in the neighborhood". Think I live in the deep South? Nope, I live in a friggin coastal city in California!
Anyways, back to Asian males. Like it or not Asians are a minority in North America, where white American culture is dominate (and exported around the globe). But I'm going to step aside and take a different approach on this.
People in different geographic regions tend to have their own distinct physical appearances and attributes. Common examples include darker skin versus pale skin, taller height versus. shorter height, etc. Prior to the spread of rail transportation, most people lived and died in the same area where they were born. Contact with outsiders were fairly limited for most, and you generally hanged out with your own people.
But things changed from late 1800s to 20th century -- revolutions, WW1, WW2, rail, personal auto, urbanization, etc. all contributed to mass shifting/migration of people. Then suddenly people who previously didn't mix much, found themselves living together in the same city. People with different physical attributes, skin color, facial appearance, body height, etc. all living in close proximity to each other.
A common physical attribute that is considered desirable for men is body height. What happens if you mix a group of people with taller genes, with a group of people with shorter genes in the same location? The presence of many taller men changes the general population's expectations, which often results in height discrimination in social and economic areas. This form of discrimination is called Heightism. It's like a transition from shorter kids being picked up in school playgrounds, to shorter men being picked on when they're adults.
Some of you might argue that there has always been a number of taller vs. shorter people in any racial or ethnic group. Yes there's a bell curve for every group, but what I'm referring to is mixing a group with a a bell curve to the right with another group that has bell curve to the left.
The average height of American men is 5'9", but 90% of American CEO's are 6' or taller. 30% of American CEO's are 6'2"+, while only 3.9% of US population is 6'2". There are many studies on this subject that you can research on the web. One report concludes that statistically, taller men make +$800/year per inch of height vs. shorter men in the US. Also, if you ask many American women, they want to date 6' tall guys. I have one Vietnamese lady friend who would only date men who are 5'10" or taller. What percentage of Vietnamese men are 5'10"+? If she still lived in Vietnam she wouldn't have this kind of expectation, but being here in Los Angeles, and seeing more taller men, changed her expectations in what is acceptable for a BF or husband. She's 5'4" BTW.
In China, some people go through extreme measures to increase their height via surgery. Why do you think they have to do that? Northern Chinese are about 3"-4" taller than Southern Chinese. In old days people stayed in their villages, now they get up and move around to the cities. An influx of taller men from Northern China changed people's expectations. Even if the taller Northerners are a minority, employers want to hire taller men and women want to marry taller husbands.
What are the Chinese Navy's requirement for recruits?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/4762803.stm
"Good looking, tall (1.7m+), and polite."
So you see, while many Asians complain about being discriminated in the US because of physical attributes, the same level of discrimination exists back home too. We have laws against discrimination based on age, gender, race, but not physical appearance and body height. Why is that? A Vietnamese male friend of mine, who's 5'2", asked me that question once, but I had no answer for him (more on what happened to him in later post).
I picked height discrimination, because that's a fairly universal issue that most of you, regardless of race or background, can identify with. There are many other areas where men, or specifically Asian men might be discriminated against in a highly competitive environment. If you find yourself in such situation, you have the choice of either fighting harder (becoming more competitive), relocate to another environment that's more favorable to you, or "exit" the game and find happiness doing something else. Do not under any circumstance become an Angry Asian like Kenneth Eng:
http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f ... 7/HATE.TMP
http://wcbstv.com/local/local_story_222133357.html
If you want to relocate to another country, to an environment that'd be better for you, ask Ladislav and Winston for some advice. They have a lot more experience living abroad than me and can point you to the right direction.
But if you want to stay and fight it out, read on! For those from 1.5 gen, your parents worked hard to bring you to America so you can have a better life. So what if the dating scene is more competitive? Let's tie that rising sun hachimaki, chant fighto fighto and give it a shot!