All the islands are great, they all have thier characteritics. Barbados, Jamaica & Mistique Island seem to be the most beautiful in terms of scenery & clean clear white sand beaches.
You want drama & folklore; Guyana
... also beautiful but they practice dark arts their.
Extreme sports; Trinidad, Jamaica, Curacao
Calm & serenity; Grenada ... all stores, restaurants & businesses close at 6pm .. zero nightlife, everyone's indoors asleep.
Party & nightlife; Trinidad, Barbados, Bahamas, Burmuda & Cayamn isles.
Food; Trinidad, Tobago, Jamaica, Belize
Men; entire caribbean