Study: US is an oligarchy, not a democracy
http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-27074746

Lot's of misinformation here. As one who actually studied government and worked in various branches of the government, this is what I would add.Winston wrote: ↑May 19th, 2020, 10:31 pm@WorldTraveler, @Yohan, @Contrarian Expatriate, @flowerthief00 how do you explain all these quotes about the NWO plot and conspiracy? Do you admit that there are factions of elites that do in fact want a world government and are trying to make it happen? If so, what is the size, scope and extent of this conspiracy or plot? How much of it is true and how much is exaggerated? Surely you don't claim that all this is either 100 percent true or 100 percent false right? The truth tends to be somewhere in the middle right? If so, where is that middle in your view?
Winston you are joking right ? Just go research what the central banks have been doing. These people have looted the entire planet.Winston wrote: ↑May 19th, 2020, 10:31 pm@WorldTraveler, @Yohan, @Contrarian Expatriate, @flowerthief00 how do you explain all these quotes about the NWO plot and conspiracy? Do you admit that there are factions of elites that do in fact want a world government and are trying to make it happen? If so, what is the size, scope and extent of this conspiracy or plot? How much of it is true and how much is exaggerated? Surely you don't claim that all this is either 100 percent true or 100 percent false right? The truth tends to be somewhere in the middle right? If so, where is that middle in your view?
Contrarian Expatriate wrote: ↑May 19th, 2020, 11:48 pmTrump was a bit of an anomaly because he was not funded nor controlled by elites, but his administration and his bureaucracy is full of people undermining him and doing the bidding of entrenched elites and that is what he means by draining the swamp.
Ok @Contrarian Expatriate so you do ADMIT that the US is an oligarchy rules by elites and corporations and bankers. Ok good. Nice. However, you said that there is no "hidden cabal" or "deep state" or shadow government" ruling America from behind the curtains? Well didn't you see these quotes above? How much CLEARER can it get than this???!!! LOOK AGAIN! Clearly these quotes indicate a hidden cabal or shadow government or deep state or invisible hand right? It cannot be more clearer in plain English! How do you not see that? Is it because your male stubborn mind rejects all data that doesn't fit into your belief system and world view? See the underlined parts below.Contrarian Expatriate wrote: ↑May 19th, 2020, 11:48 pmLot's of misinformation here. As one who actually studied government and worked in various branches of the government, this is what I would add.Winston wrote: ↑May 19th, 2020, 10:31 pm@WorldTraveler, @Yohan, @Contrarian Expatriate, @flowerthief00 how do you explain all these quotes about the NWO plot and conspiracy? Do you admit that there are factions of elites that do in fact want a world government and are trying to make it happen? If so, what is the size, scope and extent of this conspiracy or plot? How much of it is true and how much is exaggerated? Surely you don't claim that all this is either 100 percent true or 100 percent false right? The truth tends to be somewhere in the middle right? If so, where is that middle in your view?
- Anyone who has studied government knows that the USA is not a democracy, it is a republic, or as some would say, a representative democracy. Politicians and journalists like to claim that we live in a democracy, but that is part demagoguery and part ignorance. Our Constitution specifically requires that people elect representatives to rule the nation as a protection against the tyranny of the majority.
- Yes, most nations are ruled either directly or indirectly by elites. The United States included but this is not by design, but by consequence of tradition, wealth, and influence. Since political power in, in part, flows from wealthy political contributors like corporations, wealthy individuals, and powerful fundraisers, these can be said to be elites and members of the Oligarchy. But the oligarchy also includes powerful journalists, publishers, academics, and others who are low profile.
- The federal and state government officials do sometimes do the bidding of the elites who help put then there, but these officials and the bureaucrats actually have the day to day power of government, not "the elites." But, sometimes elites become government officials (Clintons, Bushes, Obamas) so that is where the power of the elites become supercharged.
- International elites do meet at exclusive organizations like The Bilderberg Meeting, The Council on Foreign Relations, etc., but these are not to plot conspiracies, but to discuss and coordinate policies to support back home.
- Yes, there is a set of leftist or progressive elites to support a globalist agenda. People like George Soros, Mark Zuckerberg, and others do seek to finish the job of pushing for more centralized alliances like the EU. However, there is considerable pushback from other elites who resist these monumental changes.
Politics tends to be a clash of the interests of power elites. Whichever side can mobilize their political bases better, can take control of executive and legislative positions. But they are primarily working to advance the policy agendas of the elites who put them in power.
Trump was a bit of an anomaly because he was not funded nor controlled by elites, but his administration and his bureaucracy is full of people undermining him and doing the bidding of entrenched elites and that is what he means by draining the swamp. But to get his agenda implemented, Trump has to make deals with conservative elites in Congress so he is not in the free and clear.
But I ask people to quit thinking there are nefarious elements hunkered down to rule us like puppets. There are secretive elements of elites in intelligence organizations as we have been seeing in the news, but these elites are fighting for the leftist agenda while Trump is fighting for the rightist agenda with less of his people in place.
Obama's 8 years saw a massive turnover in terms of replaced bureaucrats so Trump needs years to undue what Obama still has in place. This is part of the checks and balances the framers of the Constitution wanted to see.
Slow your roll there ace. I did not say that the oligarchy RULES the United States, I said that one merely exists and exerts INFLUENCE on how the United States is ruled. Don't try to make illogical leaps from what I mentioned.
I did not say that nor did I even give my opinion on it. You're so desperate to have this silly discussion that you are misquoting me. Don't do that.Winston wrote: Ok good. Nice. However, you said that there is no "hidden cabal" or "deep state" or shadow government" ruling America from behind the curtains?
Surely you are not considering unverified quotes as evidence, let alone CREDIBLE EVIDENCE! You really need to get a grip on reality @Winston. And what does any of that have to do with conspiracy as it is legally defined?Winston wrote: Well didn't you see these quotes above? How much CLEARER can it get than this???!!! LOOK AGAIN! Clearly these quotes indicate a hidden cabal or shadow government or deep state or invisible hand right? It cannot be more clearer in plain English! How do you not see that? Is it because your male stubborn mind rejects all data that doesn't fit into your belief system and world view? See the underlined parts below.
They are not unverified quotes. Didn't you read or see the link from WIkipedia? They are all documented and sourced and LEGIT quotes!Contrarian Expatriate wrote: ↑June 25th, 2020, 2:32 pmSlow your roll there ace. I did not say that the oligarchy RULES the United States, I said that one merely exists and exerts INFLUENCE on how the United States is ruled. Don't try to make illogical leaps from what I mentioned.
I did not say that nor did I even give my opinion on it. You're so desperate to have this silly discussion that you are misquoting me. Don't do that.Winston wrote: Ok good. Nice. However, you said that there is no "hidden cabal" or "deep state" or shadow government" ruling America from behind the curtains?
Surely you are not considering unverified quotes as evidence, let alone CREDIBLE EVIDENCE! You really need to get a grip on reality @Winston. And what does any of that have to do with conspiracy as it is legally defined?Winston wrote: Well didn't you see these quotes above? How much CLEARER can it get than this???!!! LOOK AGAIN! Clearly these quotes indicate a hidden cabal or shadow government or deep state or invisible hand right? It cannot be more clearer in plain English! How do you not see that? Is it because your male stubborn mind rejects all data that doesn't fit into your belief system and world view? See the underlined parts below.
If you bring up something worth discussing, I might weigh in. Short of that, don't waste my time with paranoia and tall tales.
This is the most circle-jerk of a discussion I have yet seen on this forum. I refuse to be part of it.Winston wrote: ↑June 25th, 2020, 2:41 pmThey are not unverified quotes. Didn't you read or see the link from WIkipedia? They are all documented and sourced and LEGIT quotes!Contrarian Expatriate wrote: ↑June 25th, 2020, 2:32 pmSlow your roll there ace. I did not say that the oligarchy RULES the United States, I said that one merely exists and exerts INFLUENCE on how the United States is ruled. Don't try to make illogical leaps from what I mentioned.
I did not say that nor did I even give my opinion on it. You're so desperate to have this silly discussion that you are misquoting me. Don't do that.Winston wrote: Ok good. Nice. However, you said that there is no "hidden cabal" or "deep state" or shadow government" ruling America from behind the curtains?
Surely you are not considering unverified quotes as evidence, let alone CREDIBLE EVIDENCE! You really need to get a grip on reality @Winston. And what does any of that have to do with conspiracy as it is legally defined?Winston wrote: Well didn't you see these quotes above? How much CLEARER can it get than this???!!! LOOK AGAIN! Clearly these quotes indicate a hidden cabal or shadow government or deep state or invisible hand right? It cannot be more clearer in plain English! How do you not see that? Is it because your male stubborn mind rejects all data that doesn't fit into your belief system and world view? See the underlined parts below.
If you bring up something worth discussing, I might weigh in. Short of that, don't waste my time with paranoia and tall tales.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shadow_go ... spiracy%29
If you see my quotes above, they are all sourced and legit and real. You can google them yourself. Don't make up stuff CE and pretend that real quotes are not real. They are NOT unverified. Why do you try to deceive yourself and others?
Are you saying that a hidden cabal or shadow government or deep state has nothing to do with a conspiracy? Huh? Are you trying to play with semantics and mince words? If a hidden cabal is ruling from behind the scenes with no accountability, and doing bad things, then yeah that fits the definition of a conspiracy.
If I am misunderstanding you, then please explain yourself clearly please. Are you saying conspiracies don't exist? Or do they? Which conspiracies exist and which are true?
Is there a hidden cabal controlling things in America or not? If so, how much power and control do they have?
Did you read all the quotes above? They definitely spell out clearly that America is ruled by a hidden elite cabal. It's in clear plain English. Do you deny it or not?
If we have a misunderstanding then can you please spell out your position please?
Do conspiracies exist or do they not exist at all?
Can you be specific and concrete and not play games?