
The issue though is that about 25% of them are fat hogs, like this:

So, even if we pretend hypergamy doesn't exist, if you are a man who falls in the bottom 25% you are going to get stuck with a fat hog.
"I'm not fat, why should I have to be with a fat girl?"
Because the weights of the genders are imbalanced and there are more fat women than fat men. Men realize they need to be fit in order to stand a chance with American women. Women realize that they have plenty of male options even if they are obese. So the end result is there are far more fat women than fat men. And if you are a male in the bottom 25% of looks, the best you can hope for is a hideously obese hambeast.
It doesn't matter what the top 75% of women look like, because your options are the bottom 25%. This is why it is so important that if you are in the bottom 25% of looks, you go to a country where the bottom 25% of women are not fat like in the USA. In Colombia, for example, there are almost zero fat women.